@hubbawubba So because the engine can't, that excuses it from being criticized for not doing what it was supposed to do? mkay.
Seriously though, that doesn't refute what she's saying at all, let me try to make a hopefully better response.
@psychobilly It says realistic because that was what it was going for, with the overall, and much more important goal of improving the textures from what it originally was. That's all that really matters, is it improved or not improved, and with the side goal of "realistic", does it somewhat improve the realism. What I'm trying to get at is that whether or not it achieves realism is kind of a nit-pick, and what does matter is whether or not it actually improves upon the actual textures of the original game.
tldr; Psychobilly is kind of right... but it really doesn't matter.