SCP-1025's function is completely wrong

#1
if you read http://www.scp-wiki.net/scp-1025 more thoroughly, SCP-1025's effect is not actually "gives you diseases when you read entry about disease.", it actually gives you hypochondria(fear of diseases). notice how in the test log, the guy who read the entry on cancer of the lungs never actually showed any signs of lung cancer beyond coughing, and how the researchers seemed to be constantly exaggerating and justifying the effects of the scip?

i know changing this might not be feasible at this point, considering the erroneous interpretation of this SCP has been deeply engrained in the SCP containment breach fandom. but since regalis seems to be trying to keep the game as "canon" as possible, i thought i'd just point this out.

note: sorry for my terrible grammar. english isn't my first language.

Re: SCP-1025's function is completely wrong

#2
SCP-1025 wrote:"Readers of the book seem to exhibit symptoms of any disease they read about. The effect can take between █ and ██ hours to manifest. (See Test Log)"
No, the readers do not actually get the diseases, but they exhibit the symptoms of said diseases. If you were to get certain fatal diseases, you would get the symptoms of these diseases and you could possibly end up dying.

Edit: Forget this post, I misunderstood the SCP.

Code: Select all

Omniary: fuck you anglerfish can't smell
Dr. Trialtrex21: how you know bitch
Omniary: it probably could smell you though
could probably smell your fucking dank ass nasty powersuit structure gel trog ass enslaved protein bullshit sloshing in your suit from a mile away

Re: SCP-1025's function is completely wrong

#3
Trialtrex21 wrote:
SCP-1025 wrote:"Readers of the book seem to exhibit symptoms of any disease they read about. The effect can take between █ and ██ hours to manifest. (See Test Log)"
No, the readers do not actually get the diseases, but they exhibit the symptoms of said diseases. If you were to get certain fatal diseases, you would get the symptoms of these diseases and you could possibly end up dying.
the description isn't actually entirely accurate, as it was written by people affected by SCP-1025's hypochondria effect.

if you read the comments section of the SCP itself, the author (lasergoose) states that "it gradually convinces people that those around them are horribly infected with bad things". basically, it's webMD as an SCP.

Re: SCP-1025's function is completely wrong

#4
Niblic wrote:the description isn't actually entirely accurate, as it was written by people affected by SCP-1025's hypochondria effect.

if you read the comments section of the SCP itself, the author (lasergoose) states that "it gradually convinces people that those around them are horribly infected with bad things". basically, it's webMD as an SCP.
Yes, but the problem with this is that the SCP article itself says that they exhibit effects of the disease. Just because the author said something like this in the comments doesn't make it completely canon. The only canon is what is written in the articles.

We aren't basing our canon off of what the comments section says. We are basing it off of what the articles actually say.

Edit: My apologies. I seem to have misunderstood the SCP. However, the player still feels the effects of the disease read, which is what the SCP does. You only exhibit these effects, but don't actually contract it.

Code: Select all

Omniary: fuck you anglerfish can't smell
Dr. Trialtrex21: how you know bitch
Omniary: it probably could smell you though
could probably smell your fucking dank ass nasty powersuit structure gel trog ass enslaved protein bullshit sloshing in your suit from a mile away

Re: SCP-1025's function is completely wrong

#5
Trialtrex21 wrote:
Niblic wrote:the description isn't actually entirely accurate, as it was written by people affected by SCP-1025's hypochondria effect.

if you read the comments section of the SCP itself, the author (lasergoose) states that "it gradually convinces people that those around them are horribly infected with bad things". basically, it's webMD as an SCP.
Yes, but the problem with this is that the SCP article itself says that they exhibit effects of the disease. Just because the author said something like this in the comments doesn't make it completely canon. The only canon is what is written in the articles.

We aren't basing our canon off of what the comments section says. We are basing it off of what the articles actually say.
but the whole "hypochondria" thing isn't just based off of that single comment. it is heavily implied(and even directly stated) in the article itself.

Re: SCP-1025's function is completely wrong

#6
Niblic wrote:but the whole "hypochondria" thing isn't just based off of that single comment. it is heavily implied(and even directly stated) in the article itself.
Read my edit of the last post.

Yes, I understand this. However, the player would still exhibit the traits of the disease, despite hypochondria. They may not actually have the disease, but the whole effect of the SCP is that its supposed to make you and others think you have it.

Code: Select all

Omniary: fuck you anglerfish can't smell
Dr. Trialtrex21: how you know bitch
Omniary: it probably could smell you though
could probably smell your fucking dank ass nasty powersuit structure gel trog ass enslaved protein bullshit sloshing in your suit from a mile away

Re: SCP-1025's function is completely wrong

#7
Trialtrex21 wrote:
Niblic wrote:but the whole "hypochondria" thing isn't just based off of that single comment. it is heavily implied(and even directly stated) in the article itself.
Read my edit of the last post.

Yes, I understand this. However, the player would still exhibit the traits of the disease, despite hypochondria. They may not actually have the disease, but the whole effect of the SCP is that its supposed to make you and others think you have it.
how do you end up killing yourself because you think you have cardiac arrest?

Re: SCP-1025's function is completely wrong

#8
Niblic wrote:how do you end up killing yourself because you think you have cardiac arrest?
I can see this being a problem, but with less fatal diseases, no change should be made. It's a small SCP that can hardly be found anymore anyway.

We could just remove the cardiac arrest and keep the other diseases.

Code: Select all

Omniary: fuck you anglerfish can't smell
Dr. Trialtrex21: how you know bitch
Omniary: it probably could smell you though
could probably smell your fucking dank ass nasty powersuit structure gel trog ass enslaved protein bullshit sloshing in your suit from a mile away

Re: SCP-1025's function is completely wrong

#9
Trialtrex21 wrote:
Niblic wrote:how do you end up killing yourself because you think you have cardiac arrest?
I can see this being a problem, but with less fatal diseases, no change should be made. It's a small SCP that can hardly be found anymore anyway.

We could just remove the cardiac arrest and keep the other diseases.
alright, thanks.

Re: SCP-1025's function is completely wrong

#10
Trialtrex21 wrote: I can see this being a problem, but with less fatal diseases, no change should be made. It's a small SCP that can hardly be found anymore anyway.

We could just remove the cardiac arrest and keep the other diseases.
Could we just make the player fall unconscious and after a time he awakens with the effects of the disease just a little, A LITTLE less heavy, I mean, the player should be trembling and occasionally have a blurred seen.
SCP classified documents
SCP-895 Containment chamber modification
D-9341 memoirs
Old topics of interest
cron